Field Guide

Cherry-Picked Evidence

WHAT IT IS

Real-looking facts, chosen carefully: one study, one quote, one chart window — with everything that cuts the other way left out.


WHY IT WORKS

Each piece checks out, so the whole feels true. But truth lives in the full picture, and you're only being shown the corner of it that sells.


HOW TO SPOT IT

  • One dramatic statistic with no baseline or comparison
  • A quote or clip that starts mid-thought
  • Claims that can't be checked even in principle

HOW TO DEFUSE IT

Ask what the rest of the data looks like. If a claim can't possibly be proven wrong, it isn't carrying information.


ASK YOURSELF

What would I see if I could zoom out from this exact frame?

Get a label for the next post that does this

Share a post into Media Nutrition Label and it names the techniques the post seems to use, with one move to defuse the first.

Get Media Nutrition Label on the App Store