Field Guide

Us vs. Them

WHAT IT IS

The content sorts the world into a virtuous 'us' and a dangerous or idiotic 'them' — and invites you onto the winning team.


WHY IT WORKS

Group identity is one of the oldest levers in the brain. Once you're on a team, criticizing the claim feels like betraying the tribe.


HOW TO SPOT IT

  • "People like us understand…" framing
  • The other side shown only via its worst examples
  • Agreement framed as loyalty, doubt framed as treason

HOW TO DEFUSE IT

Swap the groups in the sentence and see if the logic survives. Judge the claim as if your own side had made it.


ASK YOURSELF

Is this telling me what's true, or telling me who I am?

Get a label for the next post that does this

Share a post into Media Nutrition Label and it names the techniques the post seems to use, with one move to defuse the first.

Get Media Nutrition Label on the App Store